Fraud Blocker
1300 068 880

Switching Interest-Only to P&I: Negative Gearing

| Last Updated November 2026
Get an obligation free counsult from Kingslend Financial today
  • Our professionalism and expertise sets us apart from other brokers.
  • We have a panel of over 50+ lenders
  • High loan approval rates
  • Efficient processes to make getting a loan simple
Get In TouchCall Us

Key Points

If you bought your investment property before 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 and your interest-only period is about to end, the tax question can be answered in one line: switching from interest only to principal and interest does not affect your negative gearing grandfathering in any way, because grandfathering attaches to the property and to each owner’s interest in it, not to the loan or the repayment type. Your acquisition date is fixed. Changing how you repay the loan cannot move it.

A property investor and financial adviser compare two organised home loan repayment arrangements at an office desk.

The harder part is cash flow. A large group of investors took five-year interest-only terms in 2021 and 2022, and those terms are rolling off now. When principal repayments start, the loan payment on the same balance commonly rises by 30% to 50%. The principal portion is not deductible, so the deductible share of each repayment shrinks a little every year from here. Meanwhile, extending interest-only means a fresh serviceability assessment under current lender rules, and lenders no longer add back a negative gearing tax benefit when they assess you. The same borrower who sailed through three years ago can fail the same test today.

By the end of this, you will know which options keep your grandfathered deductions intact, which ones quietly reduce them, and what to do if neither an extension nor a refinance is available. If you want a second set of eyes on your loan before the interest-only period expires, the team at Kingslend Financial takes messages through the website and replies within 3 business hours, or you can call 1300 068 880 to talk it through with a broker in Sydney CBD or North Parramatta.

Why a Repayment Change Does Not Affect Grandfathering

A homeowner and financial adviser review changed mortgage repayments beside a model house and financial documents.

The grandfathering rules under the 2026-27 federal budget changes test one thing: when you acquired your interest in the residential property. The cut-off is 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026, the law commenced on 29 June 2026, and the quarantining of rental losses on established property starts from 1 July 2027. Nothing in that test looks at your lender, your interest rate, your loan term or whether you pay interest only or principal and interest.

Which Properties Are Protected by the 12 May 2026 Cut-Off?

If you owned, or had a contract to buy, a residential rental property before 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026, your negative gearing treatment continues under the old rules. Rental losses from that property can still be offset against your other income, including salary.

From 1 July 2027, properties acquired after the cut-off are treated differently. Losses on established residential property are quarantined, meaning they carry forward against future rental income or a future capital gain instead of reducing your salary income now. A new build or new dwelling that adds to housing supply keeps access to negative gearing under the new rules.

Grandfathering applies per owner, per interest in the property. If you own 50% of a property bought in 2021, your 50% share is grandfathered. If you later buy out a co-owner’s share, that newly acquired share is assessed under the rules that apply at the time of that acquisition. This is one of the situations where a chat with a registered tax agent before signing anything is worth the fee.

Why the Contract Date Matters More Than Settlement Date

The test is applied on the date you entered the contract, not the date the property settled. That distinction saved a lot of people. Anyone who exchanged in April 2026 on an off-the-plan or house-and-land purchase that settles in 2027 is still assessed on the contract date, so they sit inside the grandfathered group.

Keep the contract of sale, the front page with the date of exchange, and your solicitor’s settlement statement somewhere you can find them in ten years. The ATO is likely to ask for evidence of acquisition date well after you have forgotten the details, and a scanned contract answers the question in one email. If you are buying off the plan, the risks of buying property off the plan are worth reading alongside the tax position.

Does Refinancing, Changing Lenders or Switching Repayment Types Break Grandfathering?

No. Refinancing to a new lender, changing the loan term, splitting the loan, fixing the rate, or moving between interest-only and principal and interest all leave grandfathering untouched. Ownership is the test, and a refinance does not change who owns the property.

What can cause trouble is what sits around a refinance. If you increase the loan and use the extra funds for something that has nothing to do with the property, such as a car or a holiday, the interest on that portion is not deductible. That is a purpose problem with the borrowed money, separate from grandfathering. The same logic applies when accessing equity from a grandfathered property, and it is covered in more detail in our guide on whether you lose negative gearing if you refinance.

What Changes When Interest-Only Ends?

An Australian property investor reviews home loan documents and uses a calculator at a desk while looking toward a suburban house.

Two things change on the day interest-only ends: your repayment jumps, and the deductible share of that repayment starts falling. The loan balance you were carrying now has to be cleared over a shorter remaining term, which is what drives the size of the increase.

Why Principal and Interest Repayments Rise So Sharply

During the interest-only period you paid nothing off the debt. A $700,000 loan taken over 30 years with a five-year interest-only term still owes $700,000 at the end of year five, but now has 25 years left to clear it. You are paying the same interest plus a principal repayment squeezed into fewer years.

Moneysmart publishes a clear illustration of the step-up. On a $500,000 loan over 25 years with a five-year interest-only term and a comparison rate of 4.8%, monthly repayments rise from about $2,010 to around $3,250 once interest-only ends. A borrower who took principal and interest from day one would have paid about $2,875 a month the whole way through. That gap between $2,010 and $3,250 is the number to budget for, and at higher rates the step-up is larger again.

Running your own figures through an interest only calculator or a home loan repayment calculator before the expiry date gives you months of warning instead of days.

How the Remaining Loan Term and Interest Rate Affect the New Repayment

Two levers set your new repayment: the years left on the loan term and the interest rate. A shorter remaining term forces a bigger principal repayment each month, because the same balance is being cleared faster.

Loan balance

Remaining term at IO expiry

Effect on new repayment

$700,000

25 years

Baseline step-up

$700,000

20 years (after a second IO term)

Noticeably higher again

$700,000

30 years (term extended at refinance)

Lowest monthly figure

This is why some investors refinance to a new 30-year term at the same time as switching. It spreads the principal over more years and softens the monthly hit, though it increases total loan interest paid across the life of the loan. Interest-only rates also sit above principal and interest rates with most lenders, so moving to principal and interest sometimes comes with a small rate improvement that offsets a slice of the increase.

Why Only Loan Interest Is Generally Deductible

The interest you pay on money borrowed to buy an income-producing property is deductible. The principal repayment is not. It is repayment of the amount you borrowed, so it never appears as a rental expense on your return.

That has a compounding effect. In year one of principal and interest, most of the repayment is still interest, so your deduction stays close to where it was. By year eight or nine, a growing share of each repayment is principal, and your deductible interest has fallen even if the rate has not moved. Your rental loss shrinks, your taxable income rises, and the tax saving from the property drops. If you are on a 37% marginal tax rate and your annual rental loss falls by $6,000, roughly $2,220 of tax benefit disappears with it.

Your rental income has not changed. Your out-of-pocket position has, in two directions at once.

Comparing Interest-Only and Principal and Interest for Cash Flow and Debt Reduction

Interest-only maximises cash flow, keeps deductible debt at its highest and builds no equity through debt reduction. Principal and interest reduces the loan balance, builds equity month by month and costs less in total loan interest across the loan.

Interest-only

Principal and interest

Monthly repayment

Lower

Higher (often 30-50% more)

Deductible portion of repayment

All of it

Interest only, falling each year

Loan balance after 5 years

Unchanged

Reduced

Equity built by repayments

None

Yes

Total interest over loan life

Higher

Lower

Typical interest rate

Higher

Lower

Neither one is the correct answer for every investor. A borrower with a large non-deductible home loan and a small investment loan is often better keeping the investment loan on interest-only and directing every spare dollar at the home. A borrower nearing retirement with one property and a plan to hold it forever may want the debt gone. Our comparison of interest only vs principal and interest for investment property works through both cases.

Can You Extend Interest-Only or Refinance?

A property investor compares mortgage repayment options at a desk with financial documents, a calculator, and house keys.

Extending interest-only or refinancing to a fresh interest-only term is possible, and both paths now require you to pass a full serviceability assessment at today’s standards. Two changes have made that assessment tougher than it was in 2021: the assessment buffer applied to your loan rate, and the removal of the negative gearing tax add-back that lenders once used to boost investor borrowing capacity.

Why an Interest-Only Extension Requires a New Serviceability Assessment

An interest-only extension is treated as a new credit decision, not an administrative tweak. Your lender reassesses income, existing debts, living expenses and the property’s rental income, then tests the repayment at an assessment rate above the actual rate.

There is a second squeeze inside the assessment. When lenders assess an interest-only loan, they calculate the principal and interest repayment over the remaining term, not the interest-only repayment you would be paying. Ask for another five years of interest-only on a 30-year loan that has already run five years, and the assessment is based on paying the balance off over the 20 years left after the extension. That produces a higher assessed repayment than the loan you originally qualified for. The APRA 3% serviceability buffer sits on top of that figure.

How Reduced Negative-Gearing Add-Backs Can Affect Borrowing Capacity

Australian lenders used to add back the tax benefit of negative gearing when calculating investor borrowing power, effectively treating part of your expected tax refund as income. Most have stripped that out of their calculators. The result is lower borrowing capacity on the same income, same rent and same loan balance.

For an investor with two or three properties, the difference can run into hundreds of thousands of dollars of assessed capacity. Add rate rises since 2021, higher assessed living expenses and any new debt such as a car loan or a larger credit card limit, and the picture is clear enough. A file that was comfortable in 2021 can fall short now with nothing having gone wrong in the borrower’s life. If your debt-to-income ratio is the sticking point, refinancing with a high debt-to-income ratio sets out what still works.

When Refinancing for a New Interest-Only Term May Be Harder

Refinancing to a new lender for a fresh interest-only period is the usual escape route, and three things determine whether it is open to you: your LVR, your assessed serviceability and the lender’s appetite for interest-only investment loans.

LVR does a lot of the work here. If your property value has grown since purchase and your loan balance has not moved, your LVR has fallen, which widens the range of loan products available. If you bought at a high LVR in a flat market, you may be closer to the limits, and some lenders cap interest-only lending at lower LVRs than principal and interest. Fixed-rate investors need to check the break cost on a fixed loan before moving, because a break fee can outweigh the cash flow benefit. Where an application is declined, the reason usually points to the fix, and our notes on what to do after a refinance declined outcome cover the common ones.

A mortgage broker earns their keep on this exact job, because interest-only policy varies widely between lenders and the differences are not published in a way you can compare from the outside.

What Mortgage Prison Means and the Options That May Remain

Mortgage prison is where you cannot pass a new serviceability assessment with any lender, so you cannot refinance and cannot extend, and you are left with your current lender’s terms. It is a real outcome for some investors rolling off 2021 interest-only terms.

Options that stay available:

  • Stay put and switch to principal and interest. No new assessment is required to move to principal and interest with your existing lender. The repayment rises, but the loan is safe.

  • Ask for a term extension. Some lenders will extend the total loan term, which lowers the monthly principal repayment without a full refinance.

  • Reduce the balance before expiry. A lump sum against the loan before the switch lowers the principal repayment, though it permanently reduces deductible debt.

  • Consolidate or clear other debts. Removing a car loan or reducing credit card limits can be enough to restore serviceability at a new lender.

  • Rent review. Higher documented rental income feeds directly into the assessment.

  • Sell one property. Reducing the portfolio can restore serviceability across the rest, though it triggers a capital gains calculation and, for a grandfathered property, permanently loses that protection.

Our detailed walkthroughs on what to do when interest only is expiring and getting out of mortgage prison cover the sequence to work through, and interest only home loans longer than 5 years explains where longer terms exist.

How to Protect Deductibility While Managing Cash Flow

Property investor reviewing loan repayment and cash-flow information at a home office desk.

For a grandfathered property, the deductions are the asset you are protecting, which makes how you hold your spare cash a live decision. An offset account against an investment loan reduces the interest you pay while keeping the loan balance intact, so the deductible debt survives; paying the same money off the loan reduces the interest and destroys that deductible debt permanently.

Why Paying Down an Investment Loan Can Permanently Reduce Deductible Debt

Every dollar of principal you repay on an investment loan is a dollar of deductible debt you cannot get back. Pay $50,000 off a $700,000 investment loan and the deductible balance is $650,000 from then on.

The trap is what happens next. Redraw that $50,000 to renovate your own home, and the ATO applies a purpose test to the new borrowing. Money borrowed to fund a private expense produces interest that is not deductible, even though it came from an investment loan account. You now have a mixed purpose loan, and apportioning interest across two purposes for the rest of the loan’s life is a record-keeping job nobody enjoys. Our guide on how to avoid a mixed purpose loan when debt recycling shows the structuring that prevents this.

How an Offset Account Differs From Making Extra Loan Repayments

An offset account is a transaction account linked to your loan. The balance in it is subtracted from the loan balance when interest is calculated, so $50,000 sitting in offset against a $700,000 loan means you are charged interest on $650,000. The loan balance stays at $700,000.

That difference matters for two reasons. The deductible debt is preserved at $700,000, so if you later withdraw the offset money for a private purpose, your loan interest deduction is unaffected because you have not borrowed anything new. And the money remains yours, accessible, without a redraw application or a purpose question. The cash flow effect is close to identical to an extra repayment, while the tax position and the flexibility are not.

For investors with a grandfathered property and a mortgage on their own home, the order of operations changes: spare cash goes to the non-deductible home loan first, and the investment loan gets an offset. Our comparison of debt recycling vs offset and the notes on using an offset account for an investment property go through the mechanics.

Why Re-Borrowing Requires Careful Purpose Testing

Deductibility follows the use of the borrowed money, not the security behind the loan or the name on the account. Borrow against your investment property to buy shares that pay dividends and the interest is deductible; borrow the same amount against the same property for a family car and it is not.

Where both purposes end up in one loan account, you have to apportion interest between them and keep doing it for years. Splitting the loan into separate facilities before you draw the funds keeps each purpose clean and makes your return straightforward. Our guides on how to split a home loan for investment and the difference between a top up vs refinance cover the setup. Confirm the tax treatment of any structure with a registered tax agent before you draw the money.

Which Holding Costs and Rental Expenses Need to Be Budgeted

The step-up to principal and interest lands on top of costs that are already there. When you build the new budget, include the lot:

  • Property management fees, usually a percentage of rent plus letting fees

  • Council rates and water charges

  • Landlord insurance and, for units, strata levies

  • Repairs and maintenance, plus a reserve for the hot water system or an appliance

  • Land tax, where your holdings pass the state threshold

  • Vacancy allowance of two to four weeks a year between tenants

Depreciation deserves its own note, because a depreciation schedule prepared by a quantity surveyor gives you a deduction with no cash outlay. On rental properties with newer buildings or recent renovations, it is often the second-largest deduction after loan interest, and it works to soften the tax effect as your interest deduction falls. If land tax on an investment property is new to you, check the threshold in your state before finalising the budget.

Choosing a Sustainable Path for a Grandfathered Property

A homeowner discusses property loan documents and repayment planning with a financial adviser at a bright kitchen table.

Here is how the main options compare across the four things that decide the outcome:

Option

Effect on grandfathering

Effect on cash flow

Effect on deductibility

Serviceability difficulty

Switch to principal and interest with current lender

None

Repayment up 30-50%

Deductible interest falls each year

None required

Extend interest-only with current lender

None

Repayment unchanged

Full repayment stays deductible

Full reassessment

Refinance to new lender, new interest-only term

None

Repayment unchanged

Full repayment stays deductible

Full reassessment, hardest path

Refinance to principal and interest over a new 30-year term

None

Moderate increase

Deductible interest falls, more slowly

Full reassessment

Hold cash in an offset instead of repaying principal

None

Interest cost reduced

Deductible balance preserved

None required

Sell the property

Grandfathering lost permanently

Debt cleared

No further deductions

Not applicable

Your interest-only period ending does not touch your grandfathered status, and no repayment change, lender change or loan restructure will. The pressure sits entirely in cash flow and in the shrinking deductible portion of each repayment. Work out the new principal and interest figure now, check whether an extension or refinance is available at current assessment standards, and decide where your spare cash sits before the switch happens. Confirm the tax side with a registered tax agent, run the repayment numbers on Moneysmart’s calculators or your own, and if you want a broker to test your options against current lender policy, that conversation is worth having several months before the expiry date, while you still have every option open.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will switching from interest-only to principal and interest make me lose negative gearing?

No. Grandfathering is tied to when you acquired your interest in the property, and the 12 May 2026 cut-off is tested on the contract date. Your repayment type has no bearing on it, though the deductible portion of each repayment falls as you pay down principal, because only the interest is deductible.

Does refinancing a grandfathered investment property affect its tax treatment?

No. Changing lenders, loan terms or repayment type on the same property with the same owners leaves grandfathering intact. What can create a problem is increasing the loan and using the extra funds for a private purpose, since the interest on that portion is not deductible.

Can I extend my interest-only period when it expires?

Sometimes, and it requires a full new serviceability assessment. Lenders assess an interest-only extension on the principal and interest repayment over the shortened remaining term, with an assessment buffer applied, and the removal of negative gearing add-backs has reduced investor borrowing capacity since 2021.

Why are my repayments much higher after interest-only ends?

Because you paid nothing off the balance during the interest-only years, the full loan now has to be cleared over a shorter remaining term. Moneysmart’s example shows a $500,000 loan at a 4.8% comparison rate stepping up from about $2,010 to around $3,250 a month once a five-year interest-only period ends.

Is an offset account better than paying extra off an investment loan?

For most investors with a grandfathered property, yes. An offset account reduces the interest charged while keeping the loan balance and the deductible debt intact, so withdrawing the money later for private use does not affect your interest deduction. Paying the loan down removes that deductible debt permanently.

What should I do if I cannot refinance or afford the principal and interest repayment?

Start by asking your current lender for a total loan term extension, which lowers the monthly principal repayment without a new application, and move to principal and interest with them since that needs no reassessment. Clearing a car loan or reducing credit card limits, or documenting a rent increase, can restore enough serviceability to make a refinance possible.

Related Articles

Why work with Kingslend Financial?

Mortgages Structured for Your Needs

We keep your big picture goals at the forefront and help you achieve them.

Fast Approval, Easy Process

Our applications process is straightforward and streamlined, with a quick turnaround time.

No Fees to You

We are paid by the banks for introducing loan applications and for doing the work that would otherwise be completed by one of their staff.

More Money in Your Pocket

We negotiate pricing based on the strength of your application and conduct an annual mortgage health check to make sure the banks are not overcharging you.
Get free advice

Get a free consult with Kingslend Financial

Looking for help with your home loan? Contact us today and let us know how we can help you! We will respond within 3 business hours!

Google reCaptcha: Invalid site key.

Get a Free Assessment

Want help from experts with insider experience?

Google reCaptcha: Invalid site key.

We will respond within 3 business hours!

No obligation and no cost to you!